Showing posts with label The Justice Gap. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Justice Gap. Show all posts

Wednesday, 11 December 2013

Critical Reflection of WINOL and The Justice Gap

WINOL teamed up with The Justice Gap (TJG) this semester offering the crime unit the opportunity to engage in weekly Skype conferences and pitch news stories to the editor Jon Robins. TJG is an online trade magazine, covering national stories for legal professionals; the target audience is a niche market interested in the law and justice. With a focused audience, it’s easier to target stories that will be of public interest to that particular group, but with WINOL we often debate who we are aiming our news to. I personally think we have established equilibrium by broadcasting a mixture of stories that would interest young and older age groups. Suggestions arise that if we focused on campus stories we would attract a large student population but I think this would diminish the reputation we have built of WINOL in the community. Access Winchester, which covers entertainment and reviews of 'Whats on', could focus more on campus news and events to act as a mini bulletin for the student generation, this would allow our news bulletin to focus solely on news across the Hampshire region targeting the older generation.

The collaboration of WINOL with TJG was one of the biggest changes this semester. TJG website underwent a complete makeover at the start of the term to increase search engine optimisation, and it now receives approximately 500 views daily. Contributors are legal professionals including lawyers and top QCs; which results in content that is opinionated and biased. This is why Winchester journalism students become a valuable partnership, we write objective reports steering away from the vision of campaigning. On average the time spent on TJG is approximately 4 minutes, (Alexa data 6/12/2013) regular content, including videos, is uploaded throughout the week with something new uploaded every day.

Next semester, I think the collaboration of WINOL and TJG should have a greater online presence, showcasing the partnership through a picture logo linking to a direct Winchester journalism page on TJG. Similarly this could be done with Radio so viewers can click on a picture icon to listen to the podcasts.

Social media has played a vital role in spreading stories around; with over 4500 followers on TJG, articles receive a lot of attention and approx 5-15 re-tweets for each of my articles. WINOL has just over 1500 followers on twitter which has only increased by about 150 followers since May this year. We should be following all the local charities, organisations and groups that our stories target; we are not following enough people that would be interested in our stories, and I think this would have a huge domino effect on the number of views our bulletin and website receive if we maximised the use of social media. Although we have built up a brilliant reputation on WINOL with the authorities that we interview, we need to advertise it more to make residents aware that we are a reliable source of news. If a small business group was set up we could aim to increase advertisement and marketing for WINOL.

With an assigned sub team this semester, text stories have started to improve in terms of SEO, ensuring articles have tags, focus keywords and photographs which was re-enforced by guest editor Paul Wood. Appointing a front page editor was a good decision as we can focus on what story is the most popular and continue to shuffle the website around to give a sense of a live feed. However, stories are very static from one Wednesday to the next, and in comparison to last year, where reporters were assigned to days the amount of content uploaded to the site has dipped. Earlier this year visitors to the site were spending approximately 5.16 minutes (19/5/13) and this has halved to 2.44minutes now.(Alexa figures 6/12/13) We can improve this by setting up a small team interested in news writing to turn around stories that go unused in the Google mail account, this would avoid the excuse of trying to cover a story that lacked pictures, because it was simply a text story. An example of this are the Inquests I attended at a coroner’s court, all three cases worked very well as interesting text stories but certainly not for TV, so I think we need to pay as close attention to other articles online to improve news writing skills as well as broadcast skills.

A big achievement for the team this year was winning the BJTC award: ‘Best News Day of the year’. Students received certificates for coming runner up in two other categories: 'Website of the year' and 'Radio feature of the year'. This highlights the success and commitment from the team who take pride in our student broadcast.

The first week as a Justice Gap reporter was a leap from my role as court reporter on WINOL, I found the role similar to a legal correspondent, researching and gaining knowledge in areas of civil rights and criminal justice, and often reporting on law reforms. I still attended court weekly, but took a more editorial approach allowing the other crime reporters to gain experience. I continued to offer up story ideas and coach them through what I had learned over the past year with finding out about court listings, scripting PTC, getting mugshots from Police and abiding by laws of contempt ensuring the defendant was positively identified to prevent defamation.

A personal achievement for me was breaking a big story that cameras were to begin filming inside the Court of Appeal before any other news broadcaster. I received this information after calling the press office with the initial impression that it was going to happen next week, but they informed me it was due to take place tomorrow and they sent me a press release embargoed to 6pm that day. I was proud to be part of this national buzz by sharing this exclusive news, moments ahead of SkyNews on Twitter.

Claudia Murg was a standout guest editor for me, she taught me the importance of self-reflection, planning, control and inquisitiveness she emphasised that journalism is all about contacts. Building relationships and keeping in touch with people gives you the advantage of finding out inside scoops. Taking this on board, I kept in close contact with a woman from the witness services at Winchester Crown Court, after interviewing her on a story regarding the new victim's code. I saw this as my closest chance to establish a contact from inside the court who could inform me of upcoming high profile cases, as unfortunately unlike big media agencies we cannot find out in advance what are the big cases to cover. I kept in touch with her via e-mail following the interview which led me to find out about an upcoming sexual offence case that she believed would receive a lot of media attention. To our surprise not many broadcasters covered the case and when I brought this to BBC South producer Poonam Bahal’s attention she was surprised they hadn’t covered it also. Ahead of Basingstoke Gazette who covered the trial, WINOL was the first source to break the news of this sentencing as I tweeted the judges summing up upon leaving the courtroom. This was one of my strongest packages, although it was lacking pictures, I set up an interview with the officer in charge of the case, and I was praised for having a genuine interest in the story, which came across in my PTC. For the first time I heard the victim statements read by the barrister in full before sentencing, so I did a follow up from the new code using this court report as a case study on TJG, and incorporating the view of a defence lawyer to see if it raised unrealistic expectations for victims.

In my first week the editor gave me feedback that I should be leading with the original source of quotes in regard to my article on the IPCC sign off into Cardiff Three Police corruption. I interviewed the investigative journalist Satish Sekar who worked closely on the case, and what he had to say had the power to lead the article. Journalism is about human interest and reaction, so I shouldn’t have buried his quotes lower down. I took this advice on and made a personal goal to lead every article with a top line unique to TJG.

A few examples of this are the interviews I set up with the Prison Reform Trust to get their reaction to government changes to prisoner’s privileges, the NSPCC’s response to the blocking of child abuse pornography online, and following criminal investigations into recent deaths in custody, I interviewed the director of ‘Inquest’ - a charity that carries out case work on the matter.

Common feedback in debriefs, was that we were not getting any case studies to add human interest to the story, e.g. coverage of job losses - we needed to hear from someone who had lost their job. When covering the Hillsborough Inquest, I interviewed a man who lost his brother in the crush which is a good example of getting comment from someone who it directly affects. This article alone received nearly 400 views which was ranked top three for Winchester student articles, amongst the Mansfield articles.

This was one of the first phone interviews I did, and I would jot down the key quotes throughout the conversation, this is where shorthand would come in handy, despite passing 60wpm, I found it easier to record the interview on a separate device.

The most memorable day for me was our trip to London. In one day I interviewed the country’s leading human rights Barrister Michael Mansfield and filmed David Jessel commissioner for the CCRC interviewing Eddie Gilfoyle, an alleged miscarriage of justice. The interview between Jessel and Gilfoyle was approx 40minutes, which I edited down to get to the heart of the punchy emotional impact. As you would with a voice over facts in our voice, opinion in theirs, the facts went into the article and the video highlighted his emotions.

I prepared for the Mansfield interview by researching into the high profile cases he covered and reading his book 'Memoirs of a Radical Lawyer'. That morning I was told he was launching his new chambers that day which he made clear was the news agenda he wanted to cover. I set up a YouTube account in order to upload video content to the website, and the Mansfield interview was posted online the following day receiving over 300 YouTube views. Speaking to such an influential man, there was an array of articles that could be covered on different news agendas; the privilege of keeping a shed load of stories in the can means you can pick the most suitable time to publish it. An example of this was the second Mansfield clipping on police corruption, which was topical around the time of the Plebgate scandal. I learnt that it is important to give someone the right to reply when covering a story - two legal giants Mansfield and Zander had conflicting views over legal aid funding, which is a good example of this, as I threw Zander’s opinion to Mansfield to spark a response therefore it was only fair to give Zander the right to reply. The Mansfield and Zander articles combined received over 1700 unique page views online.

The role of news editor rotated amongst reporters; although practising this role had good education value I personally think it affected the quality of WINOL's output. If it was someone’s sole responsibility they could continue to progress and enforce improvements each week. The standard of management alternates each time the role changes, affecting communication and output standard. Appointing a shadow editor would serve the same educational value, but allow one person to establish a recurring house style.

The partnership between the crime unit on WINOL with TJG helped me to broaden my skills in news gathering, writing, researching, interviewing and enrich my knowledge of national legal affairs that could be localised for WINOL. For instance I organised an interview with the Governor of Winchester Prison in our studio, which worked on both a local and national scale. This feature interview allowed me to cover several topics in depth, in comparison to needing a 20 second quote. I also got an exclusive news line here that was not covered elsewhere, regarding a new working regime for prisoners.

Finally, I feel I have demonstrated that I can carry out responsible journalism, reporting on current legal affairs and court proceedings has been an invaluable experience for me, putting myself in situations sometimes out of my comfort zone enhanced my learning. As Claudia Murg said, journalism is about being fearless and taking risks particularly at time where we have the support of our mentors and by following their expert advice we can shape our foundations in establishing a career in journalism.

Friday, 6 December 2013

Week 10: The Justice Gap

The final week of this semester is already here, but looking back over the term I am pleased with my overall performance. I have been extremely fortunate to of had the opportunity to be apart of the justice gap which has broaden my skills in research, news writing, news features, interviews and pitching stories.

I edited down the interview with Eddie Gilfoyle from our trip to London in to two parts, the emotional impact and the fresh evidence. This is an extremely powerful interview conducted by David Jessel, who was a commissioner at the CCRC when his case was referred back to the Court of Appeal.

Eddie was convicted of the murder of his wife Paula, who was heavily pregnant at the time she was found hanged in her garage. Eddie maintains his innocence and continues to fight to clear his name. He served 18 years in prison, and was released on parole in 2010. Since his release new evidence has come to light that the police have been sitting on crucial material that would clear his name and tell a completely different story had this evidence surfaced at trial. In court his wife's persona was painted as a happy bubbly person, but the jury were unaware of her diaries which were handed over to Eddie's legal team in 2010. The police kept these diaries hidden for 17 years, which allegedly show there was evidence of suicidal thoughts.


‘The life I had is gone, they killed Eddie Gilfoyle 20 years ago’




Part two on the diaries to follow shortly. 

Saturday, 30 November 2013

Week 9 update

Justice Gap

In recent media there has been a few reports on criminal investigations into the treatment and care of mental health sufferers who have died in police custody. I felt this was an issue that the justice gap should cover following the alarming coverage of police misconduct in the press. The charity INQUEST which offers free advice to bereaved families has carried out a lot of casework which covers deaths in all forms of custody and detention, including prison, police, immigration and psyciatric detention. I spoke to the co-director of the charity who was preparing a report to brief MPs ahead of a parliamentary debate that day, she informed me of this therefore I wanted to address it to get fresh quotes rather then using the press release statement that was issued online.

INQUEST calls for action on ‘depressing regularity’ of deaths in custody


WINOL

WINOL this week was a huge push to get the second years to fill the bulletin, with the third year reporters all covering their own private projects it was down to the second years to bring in the stories. It has to be said that there was a disheartening attempt to bring in stories, and to see some reporters settle for an OOV when we were extremely light on packages made the editors job even more difficult as we had to find solutions to fill the bulletin. Luckily we had a reporter turn around a 2 minute package on the day which covered our award success; this was extremely efficient and appropriate considering it's not everyday we win awards. The biggest improvement this week was the use of case studies. In previous weeks this was a major disappointing factor that was addressed as people were broadcasting stories on job losses and cuts but there was no case study to illustrate how it was affecting people directly. Taking this on board reporters brought in two case studies this week which worked really well in adding human interest. Case studies add a depth to the piece which address the opinions of those involved, rather then just reporting on the facts. I thought the new editor this week did a good job in pushing reporters to continue to find another story if it fell through, consistently coming up with suggestions and solutions to encourage reporters.

I think the fact we now have a front page editor, and strong subs, the articles on the website are improving, and the regularity of changing the news around to suit what is receiving the most traffic is helping to lift the site. It feels as though there is more of a 'live' feed of news, compared to static stories that don't change until the next Wednesday. This can only continue to get better as reporters get into the habit of text stories.


Friday, 22 November 2013

Week 8: The Justice Gap

On Monday the biggest breaking story on the Today programme was the announcement that internet companies Google and Microsoft were going to block 100,000 search engine results relating to images of child abuse. This was the top story for most papers, and certainly breaking news for online websites. We agreed in the Skype conference that we had covered a lot of miscarriage of justice stories, and that we needed to add variation to the website. Therefore, I suggested to the editor that I could cover this topic with it being a big current issue. To move the story on from the new changes made I wanted to get the angle that addressed the victims involved, I did this by contacting children's charities to get their view on on the new changes. After speaking with the media team at the NSPCC I was in contact with the head of Child Saftey Online, following the phone interview I transcribed what she said and wrote my article up that outlined what changes she felt still needed to be done. To view the article click the headline link below.

This week was a good example of how to address the people that are affected by the story rather then the story itself and move it on. This is something the editor has always been in favour of so rather then leading with the story about Google blocking child porn, I lead with the reaction by the leading children's charity. Every story in journalism has to engage human interest, if no one is affected by it no audience will want to read it, therefore getting the reaction to the initial story is really important in addressing a fresh article.

More networks spreading ‘poisonous’ child abuse imagery need to be tackled


Also this week I was covering a sexual offence court report on Winchester News Online. After speaking with the victim support group a few weeks back regarding the changes to the victims code I thought it would be good to do a follow up and re-address this story using the court report as a case study. The man was convicted of 20 offences including rape over a period of eight years, he abused women who he was seeing and therefore this was a big case whereby the victims had to come forward in court and re-live these terrible experiences. I think it's important to address the bravery of the victims as speaking up in court is a difficult process. I used the interview from the victim support group and the officer leading the case to write an article about the significance of impact statements, but to move the article on, I got the view of a defence barrister to find out how beneficial they thought this new right would be and whether it gives victims unrealistic expectations. Speaking with the barrister was really interesting to hear it from a different perspective. Although the Government have introduced this new right, the barrister pointed out how victims have always been considered throughout the process, just not in a way that exploited to the public exactly how they were feeling. That is not to say they were not considered by the judge, they always have been. The benefit of reading the statements aloud in full in court raised doubts in the barristers mind. To read the full article click the headline below.

Impact statements may raise ‘unrealistic expectations’ for victims

Friday, 15 November 2013

Week 7: WINOL & The Justice Gap

This week sparked a huge thought process for me, after Claudia Murg's visit to the newsroom I've been left thinking about where I want to go within journalism and when she asked me what my plans are, I couldn't answer her. The truth is, I'm not certain what journey I may follow, all I know is that I am going to try grab every opportunity I can with both hands, experiment, take risks, challenge myself and just see where it is that my strengths lie, and who it is along the way that I may meet. Journalism is an exciting world, it opens so many doors, it's an adventure that leads you into new realms each and every day, but you really do have to live, eat and breathe it, it's an obsession and it does become your life. It's difficult to switch off, if you disconnect yourself from the world, you've missed out, but then there are always the unexpected moments where you do turn away, and these are the times you find yourself talking to someone who has an interesting story to share. There would be no journalism without people, the subject matter is always about who is affected.

I organised an interview with Winchester Prison Governor this week for a feature interview, immediately there was problems with getting access into the prison due to health and safety regulations but a mistake I made was to not go for the next best thing and film outside. Instead he came and joined us in our WINOL studio, but there always seems to be technical problems with the studio, which meant the edit was certainly a challenge. The interview itself went well, but visually for the bulletin it was lacking pictures, we needed to see pictures of the jail to illustrate the story so that was one element missing.  When it came to deciding which part of the interview to use for the bulletin, I must admit I went with the safe option of reporting on the improvements of the prison as this had already been covered by other regional channels. As Claudia said you need to always be bringing something new, it's not journalism if someone else has already done it, which is why on reflection I feel I didn't push the story on. Click the heading to view it online:

Governor ‘confident’ Winchester prison is improving

















Having said this, I also did an extended version that did bring something new and fresh to lead with. A new working regime will be implemented into prisons at the start of this week, and therefore it has been posted up online just in time for the weekend.It also covered the debate over whether prisons should be places of rehabilitation or punishment, following on from the previous article I wrote about re-offending rates in prisons. It was really interesting to hear from a Governor's point of view whether they believe prisoners have equal human rights to us. The editor thought the interview worked really well, it had depth and substance, and it was different to a news report. To read and watch the video interview click the heading below.

New prison regime gets prisoners to work


This is an example of how a story has been found through speaking to contacts, it's before any press releases have been released, and before any other paper has covered it. A note from the debrief last week is that we need to be leading with a new story at the start of the week on the WINOL website, as too often stories have not been updated from the previous Wednesday. There is always a spike in traffic mid-week but then this dips over the weekend when there are no new stories uploaded. I have filed this article as a draft ahead of Monday morning, so that there is some fresh news to start the week.



Thursday, 7 November 2013

Week 6: Justice Gap

Prison reforms to rehabilitate offenders won’t stop re-offending


Following the prison riots at HMP Maidstone this week, I was intrigued by the cause. The riots occurred a day after the Government enforced changes to the Incentive and Earned privilege scheme. It was suspected that the clampdown on prison perks was the cause behind the riots. I wanted to look into this further, and address the question whether prisons should be there to punish prisoners, or rehabilitate them. I wrote an article on Chris Graylings rulings, but tried to move the story on by addresses whether it was actually going to help. I got in contact with the Prison Reform Trust to interview someone there who was willing to comment. Speaking with the Head of Policy and Communication, Mark Day I was able to include original quotes in my article, and give the story a fresh top line.

With this article, I tried to localise it by seeing whether there were any signs of any rebellious activity in Winchester Prison, however speaking with the Governor I was informed that HMP Winchester fully prepared the offenders in advance, and that they were aware of the changes months prior. Following this phone conversation I set up an in-studio interview with the Governor, David Rogers, to address broader prison matters. This feature interview will be broadcasted on The Justice Gap as a national angle, but locally on our weekly WINOL bulletin.

[Click the headlines to read the articles]

On the wednesday an article was published regarding the High Courts ruling which grants the right to anyone held under schedule 7 of the Terrorism Act to have a solicitor present face-to-face.  Jon credited this as a 'speedy' turn around, as it was up on the site within an hour of him messaging me the story.

Terrorist suspects given right to solicitor present during questioning


Monday, 28 October 2013

Week 5 - The Justice Gap

Mansfield and Zander clash over legal aid funding



Professor Michael Zander came to the University of Winchester to speak at the launch of the new Crime and Justice Centre, I transcribed his lecture notes here.  During his speech he commented on the matter of legal aid funding, backing that our legal aid system is better then any other country. During the interview for the Justice Gap with Michael Mansfield I threw him the question on what he thought about this comment and he responded against what Zander had to say.

This week I realised how important it is to re-address the people you speak to and share the article you have written about them rather then shy away in hope they won't see what you reported. Mansfield responded to Zander's comments therefore we needed to give Zander the right to reply. The argument here is that Mansfield believes the system is broken, but Zander supports that the legal system still works. However, Zander wanted to make it clear that he did not think the cuts were a good thing, so an additional line that directly addressed the fact he thought the cuts were terrible was included.

Click the headline links or view the full article here. This week marked an increase in traffic to the website, peaking close to 1000 unique views daily.


Victims to be allowed to address court before sentence




Also this week, I wrote an article on the new code which gives victims the right to read out their personal statements in court. To push my article on from the recycled press release reports I wanted to get my own quotes, I also looked to localise the story in order to use it on WINOL. I wanted to add human interest to this story by speaking with a victim that would want to comment on the new changes. However I was unsuccessful at short notice when trying to get hold of a case study as there are several issues surrounding confidentiality.

After contacting the local Victim Support Group I set up a video interview with Carolyn Martin who works at the Witness Services at Winchester Crown Court who are there to support and protect victims and witnesses. The interview went well, and it was good to build a contact from within the court and introduce myself and make the publication more known to them. A short clip of the interview was used as an OOVACT on WINOL, but as the bulletin was light on stories this week, the news editor asked for approx 35 seconds to beef out the bulletin a bit more. This interview worked well both nationally and locally and therefore it was published on both the Justice Gap website, and WINOL.

Cameras begin filming courts for first time

Furthermore, on Wednesday I was working on a text story regarding the plans for cameras to film inside the courts for the first time. When this was first brought to my attention I researched it, and saw other newspapers such as The Guardian reported the proposed filming would begin on the following Monday if the legislation is approved. After phoning the Court of Appeal to get the latest information, I was informed that it had been approved and it was going to begin the next day. Speaking with the Ministry of Justice press office I was sent the latest press release which was embargoed until 6pm that day. This was a highlight for me, working on an article before another publication had reported on it, and before the breaking news was due to go live.

Using social media we tweeted the article as it was published dead on 6pm, using the hash tag #camerasincourt. The Justice Gap reported on this landmark change moments before Sky News did, which I was extremely proud of. Full article here. 



Click the headline links to view each article.

Wednesday, 23 October 2013

Week 4 - The Justice Gap: Interview with Michael Mansfield QC

Mansfield: Level of collusion between police, politicians and media is ‘disturbing’




Mansfield calls for legal profession to strike against legal aid cuts




Week Four

Following the interview with Michael Mansfield the previous week, I continued to work on editing the footage from the interview down into separate categories as there was a few news agendas to cover, including legal aid, new chambers, police corruption and miscarriages of justice to name but a few. The video's above show part one and two of the interview.

This week I focused on the comments made about the collusion amongst the press and politicians as this was extremely topical this week with the all of the national press covering the 'plebgate' row. This therefore made it current on top of updating it on the day after a senior tory called for a royal commission for police to wear microphones and cameras to record their contact with the public.

This taught me the importance of making it topical to draw attention to it, we lead with our own interview quotes from Mansfield to make the article unique to the Justice Gap by using our own source. But I made it relevant to the storm around the plebgate saga by using quotes from Nick Clegg and from other professionals off twitter, radio broadcasts and newspapers.

Every article that is written is distributed across twitter targeting those of interest. They have been receiving a lot of attention from criminal barristers and legal professionals. Click the headlines to be directed to the articles

The topic of police corruption has received masses amount of press attention recently, therefore I wanted to get in touch with the National College of Policing to organise an interview with the Chief Executive Alex Marshall. This would of worked well for WINOL, it would of localised the story for the bulletin as he is the ex-chief constable for Hampshire. I hoped to speak about the 'unspoken immunity' amongst police that Mansfield commented on and give him the right to defend the police over the negative press that they have received. After speaking with his PR regarding Mansfield's comments on the level of distrust between the police and society he was not willing to comment on the matter.




Friday, 18 October 2013

Week 2 and 3 - The Justice Gap

Week Two

This week in our Skype conference, I put forward the idea of reporting on the IPCC's update on the Hillsborough investigation. The stadium disaster is one of the biggest cases of police corruption. From the get-go the police failed the fans and families, covering up the truth of their wrongdoing. I wanted to get this message across in my article and therefore question the families on the police misconduct, especially after the pre-inquest hearing brought about new allegations that police footage may have been edited.

The Editors feedback last week was to ensure we are pushing our articles on rather then recycling press releases, finding solutions to get original quotes to make the article unique to the Justice Gap. Taking this on board I contacted the Hillsborough Justice Campaign and the Hillsborough Families support group to get a response from the people who are directly affected. I set up a phone interview with a man named Steven Kelly who sadly lost his brother in the crush, he openly was happy to comment on his feelings towards the coverup. This was a new experience for me, conducting an interview whereby it wasn't on camera, and therefore I couldn't rely on the footage to pick up the quotes. I had to write down what he was saying accurately and quickly! This is where the skill of shorthand would come in handy, therefore I am continuing to practise this skill to pick up speed.

When it comes to news writing, I've learnt that you need to lead with the best quotes, similarly to how you would in a news package by leading with your best pictures. The top line, followed by the powerful hard hitting quotes need to go straight at the top, no point in hiding them lower down as readers won't get that far. The editor praised how powerful and hard hitting the quotes were, his feedback was extremely encouraging. Initially he thought the quotes had been taken from a statement or from another publication but he was pleased to know that the quotes were all from my own source. From this week on, the importance of finding my own sources is in the forefront of my mind, adding human interest to each article is crucial and far more engaging for the readers. People who are willing to comment are on the other end of the phone, we just have to pick it up and target the people affected and willing to comment.

Click the headline below to read the full article.

Police corruption ‘rubs salt in wounds’ of Hillsborough families


Week Three

This was a big week for the Justice Gap Reporters, the editor organised a day trip to London to meet with some big names in the legal profession. First of all we headed to Hardwicke Building in Lincoln Inn where we set up our equipment in the room we had been given. We met with David Jessel who was the commissioner for the CCRC between 2000-2010 and Eddie Guilfoyle, an innocent man who is fighting to clear his name after wrongfully serving 18 years in prison for the murder of his wife. The case of this miscarriage of justice can be read here. We filmed Jessel interviewing Guilfoyle which will be uploaded on the Justice Gap website. It was an extremely interesting day to hear his story first hand and to be given the opportunity to speak with David Jessel regarding Jeremy Bamber which is a case I have closely followed.

We then moved on to Chancery lane to meet Michael Mansfield who was launching his new chambers that day. It was an absolute privilege to conduct the interview with Mansfield, who is the country's leading human rights barrister. Over the last few weeks I have been reading his book Memoires of a radical lawyer and I looked into the cases he has worked on including Birmingham 6, Stephen Lawrence, Jean Charles de Menezes, Hillsborough and most recently Mark Duggan.

Although I had a million questions I wanted to ask Mansfield, the main focus that I was informed of that morning was the launch of his new chambers, this brought to my attention that as journalists we have to be adaptable to get the freshest news scope that we can find. We must also take into consideration when dealing with influential professionals, there will be questions they won't be able to answer, in this instance there were several topics he was unable to comment on, such as Hillsborough as he is currently working on this case. His previous chambers Tooks closed down due to government cut backs on legal aid, and with the new chambers opening that day we made this the primary focus to lead with, turning the story around within a day to keep it current. You can watch this part of the interview here.

I transcribed the video to include the quotes in my article which accompanied the video. Doing a lengthy interview was good practise for me, as it allowed me to consider leads into different news agendas, cutting down the footage into different topics.

It was a real pleasure to meet Mansfield, an extremely valuable experience. I look forward to sharing the other parts of the interview with you, which will go up on the Justice Gap website next week.


Michael Mansfield QC with the Crime Unit

Saturday, 5 October 2013

Back to Work, Week One

Winchester News Online has been sponsored by The Justice Gap this year, it is our role as the crime unit to write news reports weekly for the website, which plays host to many articles relating to the law and justice. I will keep you updated on the stories I am working on, by linking them through my blog. You will be able to view each article by clicking on the headline links.

Week One


During the Skype conference, the editor suggested several different current news ideas that we could write about. Personally I found the IPCC's statement regarding their satisfaction with the South Wales Police's investigation into police corruption over the Lynette White case the most interesting. It is an extremely high profile miscarriage of justice, which relates to my own personal interest within the legal system, therefore I was extremely engaged into researching this case. 

A phone interview was set up with the investigative journalist Satish Sekar, who worked closely on this case, to find out what he believed should come from these conclusions. The beauty of broadcast is that we can rely on the camera to get all our quotes down accurately, however with print I had to adjust to listening to the spoken quotes, and selectively writing these down whilst thinking about what question I wanted to discuss next. 

The editor suggested that I could of developed this article further by leading the article with Satish's comments. Our own quotes from the investigative journalist had the power to take the story on, I could of included a lot more coverage on what he had to say, and it shouldn't have been as low down in the article. This feedback taught me that we should always lead with the original source, that will attract human interest.

To view the article click the headline link below. 


Broadcast journalism is what WINOL specialises in, after delivering court reports weekly last semester it was something I became a lot more confident with, I built up contacts within Hampshire police and I was comfortable knowing what needed to be done. However, print journalism is something I have not had a great amount of experience doing, therefore this has been a challenge for me, and one that I am eager to practise and improve on. To be commissioned to write articles is the perfect opportunity for me to improve upon a personal weakness.

A week from now, the team will be down in London, we will be producing video interviews with David Jessel, Eddie Gilfoyle and Michael Mansfield QC. I have been preparing for the interview with human rights Barrister Michael Mansfield who has covered many high profile cases such as Birmingham 6, Hillsborough, Steven Lawrence, and more recently Mark Duggan, to name just a few.

Aside from working on The Justice Gap, the crime unit will continue to produce video reports for WINOL. I went down with the new crime reporters to Winchester Crown Court this week to take them through the stages of producing a report - from sitting in court, to passing the legal requirements through to obtaining convicted photographs and scripting for broadcast. 

This week Ian Anderson, the former editor of BBC 10 o'clock news was the guest editor. He was extremely impressed with the professionalism of the WINOL team. He gave individual feedback to all the reporters on their packages, and questioned the news editor on his running order of the stories. This was the first week back, and with some people producing packages for the first time there were some hiccups in terms of audio and camera work. Ian commented on how equally important it is to have good audio to match the visuals, begin with the best shots first, the first 20 seconds of your video need to be the most engaging, and give the viewer a reason to want to continue watching. 

I will be the news editor next week, my main goal is to ensure that all reporters focus on the quality of their output, they proved last week that the content can be superb so my main aim is to ensure the quality of the filming is up to scratch, paying close attention to the lighting, rule of thirds, and sound.



Wednesday, 25 September 2013

WINOL returns

Back to WINOL

The final year is now amongst us, and we're all back ready to kick start another successful year of WINOL. Together with the second years we have formed a new team, who is ready to embrace new changes and exciting challenges. Personally, I chose to keep my role as chief crime and court reporter as it's the beat I have the most engagement with both in and out of WINOL, and therefore I would like to continue to develop my skills and knowledge within a patch I am most interested in. The Innocence project is also vast approaching which I am extremely eager to begin investigating.

New Changes 

The biggest change to my role this semester is the development of a crime unit, in previous semesters it has been the solo court reporter but now with a group together we can actively produce a greater amount of content for online and broadcast. An extremely exciting proposal has been offered to us by The Justice Gap will now be working in partnership with Winchester News Online, this is a honourable experience for us as students to produce news reports for a national established website. Weekly we will be in contact with the editor Jon Robins to discuss current criminal affairs, whereby he will commission us to write news reports. Currently the website has a lot of comment analysis and timeless blog posts but the idea with working with WINOL is to adapt a news section offering readers reaction to current breaking stories. 


The Justice Gap


The Justice Gap is an online magazine about the law and justice. It has been running for two years now with the aim to shine a light and expose elements of the justice system that do not receive enough coverage in the mainstream media. It has adopted a particular point of view which is left leaning and liberal - campaigners, lawyers and professionals involved in the law contribute towards writing comment pieces on the site on topics such as human rights, civil liberties, consumer law and miscarriages of justice.

Primarily the site was set up to promote 'access to justice' as there are doubts that the system isn't working; it is there for people who may be out of touch with there rights thus struggling to get justice.  

Michael Mansfield QC who is the leading human rights lawyer contributes articles towards the justice gap, which he refers to as "The section of the public too poor to afford a lawyer and not poor enough to qualify for legal aid". David Jessel who was a commissioner for the CCRC is another key figure involved in The Justice Gap who explains it as the difference between law and justice. 

In collaboration with The Justice Gap we will also be doing some video interviews with some high profile professionals in the legal field, so keep your eyes peeled - more details to follow soon!